My
next subject in this series differs from my previous ones in that she
is actually a sidekick and not the feature character. Her name was
the Kitten and she was the “girl wonder” to Cat-Man. This series
brings with it tons of ancillary situations, that often times I find
more fascinating than the comic strip itself.
In
1940 Holyoke Publishing introduced a new character that they called
Cat-Man. David Merrywether was the child of American circus
performers and was orphaned when bandits attacked their caravan in
the jungles of Burma. Alone in the tropical forest, he is adopted by
a tigress and becomes a feral child learning the ways of the great
cats. (Shades of Tarzan!) This jungle life leads him to develop
incredible strength, agility and the keen night vision of his four
legged brethren. Eventually he leaves this adopted homeland and
returns to America. Perhaps remembering that criminals caused the
destruction of his human parents, David puts on a cape, mask and cowl
to do battle against those who prey on the innocent.
Now
it seems to me Cat-Man’s very name would be enough to throw up
flags to the DC Comics attorneys for possible infringement against
their Batman character. But that situation is further exacerbated by
Merrywether’s costume, which is clearly patterned on the dark
knight’s. True the coloring is far different but jeez, both hoods
include the little ears! Despite these similarities, I am unaware of
any such legal actions occurring and Cat-Man enjoyed a reasonably
long run in the Golden Age.
In
CAT-MAN COMICS #5 he meets 11-year-old Katie Conn, who like himself
is the child of circus folk. She lost her parents in a fire and was
living with an uncle that was forcing the young girl to use her
acrobatic training to commit robbery. As Cat-Man he intervenes and
her uncle is sent to prison. This leaves her without a guardian and
David steps in to assume that role. He confides to her his dual
identity and brings her in as his crime-fighting partner. Here is
that climactic page.
Okay,
lets step back a moment and wallow in the ‘W-T-F’ factors. Yeah I
know it’s just comics and all but in order to successfully get
people to suspend their disbelief in larger things like super powers,
you do need to ground them in reality a little bit. So lets examine
what’s wrong with this picture. Sure once again Batman provides a
precursor with Bruce Wayne’s guardianship of Dick Grayson. That
strip gets a pass on this for a couple reasons. Wayne is a notable
figure in the community and clearly has the financial means to
successfully care for Grayson as a single parent. These same funds
give Wayne the services of high-powered attorneys that most surely
could orchestrate such an unconventional arrangement. Merrywether
lacks neither stature nor means to accomplish this and further he is
an active duty member of the US military. How would any judge
reasonably grant him custody of Katie? Now maybe it’s just a modern
affectation on my part but does anyone else out there feel that there
is something fundamentally creepy about the living arrangements
between ‘Kitten’ and ‘Uncle David’?
Here
is a typical early adventure as drawn by Charles Quinlan. I remarked
upon him previously on the Miss Victory posting for MHA.
Another
controversial issue raised by the Cat-Man strip is child
endangerment. Sure it’s one that’s skirted by virtually all
strips that feature adolescent sidekicks. But Cat-Man seems to place
Kitten in some pretty extreme circumstances. Witness this more lurid
episode as drawn by Don Rico. If you found the character of Hit Girl
in film Kick-Ass to be shocking, then let me know your feelings about
the last page of this tale.
The
final example is from late in the run. This one’s drawn but the
great Bob Fujitani. Under his draftsmanship Kitten seems a bit more
mature and grim.
With only a 12 year age difference, and Cat-Man being 28 to a 16 year old Kitten during their final adventure in 1946, it's pretty obvious where the two of them were heading. As long as she was age of consent, why not?
ReplyDeleteBTW, WW2 France fell under Napoleonic Law, and the age of consent was 13, and only 15 even today. 14 year old Kitten was indeed legal in that 1944 story with the Four Horsemen in Nazi occupied France.